Brown Butter Bakery
← Back to shop
Hand-Rolled Bagels
breadbreakfastsavory

Hand-Rolled Bagels

5.0(1)read reviews

$18.00 per half dozen

Old-fashioned bagels: hand-rolled, cold-proofed overnight for flavor, kettle-boiled, then baked until the crust is deep gold and crackly and the inside is dense and chewy. Each half dozen comes as three plain and three everything (sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, and flaky salt) — or tell us in your order notes if you'd like all of one kind. Best the morning they're baked, and they toast beautifully for days after.

Up to 8 per order. Need more? Email us.

Lead time
Order at least 24 hours ahead
Allergens
Contains wheat, sesame. Made in a kitchen that handles dairy, eggs, and nuts.

From customers

Reviews

5.0

1 verified review

  • 5 stars1
  • 4 stars0
  • 3 stars0
  • 2 stars0
  • 1 star0
  • Long Island Quality

    Turned out really great

    Ashim B. · September 2026 · ✓ Verified purchase

    Anika replied

    Thank you.

You might also like

Vanilla Bean Confetti Cupcakes

Buttery vanilla bean cake speckled with rainbow confetti, topped with tall swirls of vanilla buttercream.

Themed Party Cupcakes

Themed Party Cupcakes

$60.00per dozen

Hand-piped cupcakes decorated to your theme — puppy faces, piñatas, cactus gardens, or whatever the party calls for.

Triple Coconut Layer Cake

Triple Coconut Layer Cake

$85.00per 8-inch cake

Three tall layers of coconut cake, coconut cream filling, and a snowfall of sweetened flaked coconut.

Mini Saint-Honoré

Mini Saint-Honoré

$36.00per set of 4

The French classic in miniature — caramel-glazed cream puffs on crisp pastry, crowned with vanilla chantilly.

Mango & Pineapple Pavlova

Mango & Pineapple Pavlova

$55.00per pavlova (serves 10–12)

A crisp meringue crown with a marshmallow heart, filled with vanilla cream and heaped with mango and pineapple.

Mini Blueberry Pavlovas

Mini Blueberry Pavlovas

$30.00per half dozen

Individual meringue nests with vanilla cream and a crown of powdered-sugar blueberries.

Chocolate Silk Tart

Chocolate Silk Tart

$48.00per 9-inch tart

Silky milk-chocolate cream in a dark cookie crust, ringed with whipped cream and toasted coconut.

Black Forest Cake

Black Forest Cake

$95.00per 9-inch cake

Chocolate layers, kirsch cherries, and whipped cream, armored in dark chocolate shards and gold leaf.

Chocolate Babka

Chocolate Babka

$28.00per loaf

A twisted brioche loaf laced with dark chocolate and cocoa crumble, glossy from its syrup bath.

French Macarons

French Macarons

$32.00per dozen

Delicate almond shells with ruffled feet and vanilla buttercream — flavors and colors change with the season.

Ginger Molasses Cookies

Soft, sugar-crackled molasses cookies with fresh ginger and warm spice — crisp edge, chewy middle.