Made to order · Boulder, Colorado
The Journal · Recipe

The Banerjee Thanksgiving Pies

Catering to my finicky family members during my favorite holiday.

By Anika Banerjee
A chocolate bourbon pecan pie and a pumpkin pie topped with whipped cream rosettes

Thanksgiving is the best holiday there is, and no dissent will be tolerated. It is hard to argue with the inherent message of the day— a day that reminds us to be grateful for the people in our lives, the things we have, and how fortunate we may be. Growing up though, my family was not one to celebrate it. Now do not mistake my words, they were not avoiding the holiday to refute the bountifulness and joy of the day, it was simply something they were unfamiliar with having grown up in India.

But after celebrating the day with family friends one year, I was steadfast in bringing the holiday to our home. However, this ended up presenting quite the challenge. A classic Thanksgiving dinner consists of green bean casserole, mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes, mac and cheese, stuffing, cornbread, cranberry sauce, pies, and of course, a turkey. The problem was not even that my family only has four people total, with few relatives spread across the country that were unlikely to join us. The real issue was that my mother is a vegetarian, which eliminated the turkey and stuffing from her meal. Add my sister’s pickiness, and the green bean casserole and mac and cheese were gone too. What remained was a carb- and sugar-laden meal— but I had no objections, this was a day for indulgence!

My father and I experimented for a while, trying duck one year, and telling my sister it was chicken, prompting questions like “Why does the chicken look so deflated?” and “Why is the meat so dark and fatty?” The following year we tried guinea hen and the year after we went for the more classic chicken. These all were delicious, but as a baker, my contribution to the dinner was mainly through the desserts. But once again, the finicky nature of my mother and sister reared its irritating head.

“Well I don’t like pumpkin pie!” My mother complained.

“I am not going to eat pecan pie, I am allergic!” My sister said, as though we could be fooled by the fib, knowing how frequently she would substitute ‘allergy’ for ‘dislike.’

I could see my hope for a traditional Thanksgiving slip away as yet another red mark was made beside a menu item that had to be nixed. But luckily for me, my sister enjoyed pumpkin pie, and my mother fancied pecan pie, so the two could still be made! But as I prepared the chicken with rosemary and garlic, and brushed the cornbread over with butter, I found myself bored with the overly pedestrian meal. How could I make a simultaneously traditional dinner while also having something original?

Obviously, my mind wandered to the desserts. Pumpkin pie and pecan pie? Where did these recipes give way to originality and unique flavors? So this year, I have decided to try recipe testing for a delicious, more original treat.

How could I make a simultaneously traditional dinner while also having something original?

I sat down with pen and paper, ‘Pumpkin’ emblazoned largely upon the top beside ‘Pecan.’ I tapped the edge of my pen against the counter as I pondered complementary flavors for the two pies. Pumpkin goes nicely with chocolate, but that could also overwhelm the delicate flavor of the pumpkin puree. What about caramel? It would certainly make for a rich dessert, but would it be too sweet? Too cloying? Likely. Then my mind wandered to the spices in the pie: cinnamon, ginger, clove… Ginger! That was it! Perhaps a gingersnap cookie crust was the perfect pair for the smooth, pumpkin custard.

Now pecan… An amazing pie, but unbelievably sweet from the high volume of corn syrup that glues the nuts together, paired with even more brown sugar. There was no shortage of flavors that paired well with pecans. Maple? Of course, a classic! But still too sweet. Pecan cheesecake? It could have worked, the richness and tartness of the cheese cutting the sweetness, but my mother doesn’t eat cream cheese. Sigh. I could use a drink— a drink! That’s it! Perhaps a splash of bourbon, that would certainly balance the flavors while adding some depth of flavor to the pie, and a touch of chocolate certainly couldn’t hurt!

Luckily, the pickiness of my mother and my sister did not completely bar me from my desire to add some creative flourishes to our Thanksgiving dinner, and surprisingly, they enjoyed the little tweaks to the desserts, eager to make these the new staples for the Banerjee Thanksgiving.

A pumpkin pie with a gingersnap crust, and a chocolate bourbon pecan pie! If you are feeling bored from the monotony of the Thanksgiving menu, perhaps these could be the fix for you too.

Recipe one

Pumpkin Pie with a Gingersnap Crust

Makes one 9-inch pie

Crust

  • 3 cups Anna’s Thins Swedish Gingersnap crumbs
  • 2 tsp cinnamon
  • ¾ cup melted butter

Filling

  • 15 oz can Libby’s Pumpkin Puree
  • 1 cup evaporated milk
  • 3 eggs
  • ½ cup brown sugar
  • ¼ cup granulated sugar
  • 2 tsp cinnamon
  • 1 tsp ginger powder
  • 1 tsp pumpkin pie spice
  • A pinch of salt

Method

  1. A 9-inch pie tin is needed for this recipe. Preheat the oven to 350°F.
  2. Combine the gingersnap crumbs with the cinnamon and butter in a large bowl until the mixture is tacky and holds its shape when pressed.
  3. Using your hands or a spoon, press the gingersnap crust to line the pie tin evenly. Bake in the oven for ten minutes and then set aside.
  4. In a stand mixer or a large bowl, whisk together the eggs, sugars, spices, and salt until well combined.
  5. Add the pumpkin puree and once well mixed, stir in the evaporated milk until the custard is nice and smooth.
  6. Pour the custard into the prepared crust and bake in the oven for 55–60 minutes until the custard slightly wobbles in the very center.
  7. Cool and serve with fresh whipped cream.
Recipe two

Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie

Makes one pie

Pie crust

Any recipe for a nice, buttery crust.

Pecan pie filling

  • 1 ½ cups crushed pecans
  • 1 cup halved pecans (to arrange on top)
  • 3 eggs
  • ½ cup brown sugar
  • ¼ cup granulated sugar
  • ⅓ cup dark brown corn syrup
  • ⅓ cup light corn syrup
  • 1 tablespoon vanilla paste
  • ¼ cup bourbon
  • ¾ cup semi-sweet chocolate chips

Method

  1. Begin by blind baking your pie crust of choice and setting aside.
  2. Preheat the oven to 375°F.
  3. In a stand mixer or in a large bowl with a hand mixer, combine the eggs, corn syrups, sugars, vanilla, and bourbon until well mixed.
  4. Add in the crushed pecans and chocolate chips and stir until everything is well coated. Pour into the prepared pie crust and finish by arranging the pecan halves in concentric circles on top.
  5. Bake until slightly wobbly in the center.
  6. Cool and serve with fresh whipped cream.
Back to the Journal Place an order